[CURATE] km3io
=== Record #7382620 ===
Title: km3io
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7382620
URL: https://zenodo.org/record/7382620
This software provides a set of Python classes to read KM3NeT dataformats without having ROOT or any KM3NeT internal software installed.
Check the software checklist for the entry
-
Contains valid codemeta.json (see validator output) -
Documentation is provided in the Zenodo entry (at least through codemeta) -
a stable versioned release of the project -
It is under an open-source license (see SPDX [https://spdx.org/licenses/]) -
Follows a reasonable set of software development / software engineering practices (rough by-eye quality estimate)
Complete onboarding issue
Related onboarding issue: https://project.escape2020.de/issues/36
-
Make sure all boxes of the checklist up to "Uploaded to Zenodo" are ticked -
Tick "software checklist completed" when done with the above -
When cleared for merging, tick "Added to Zenodo community/published" and change issue status to "closed"
!! There is no codemeta file in record 7382620 !!
Merge request reports
Activity
added Ready for curation label
- Resolved by Kay Graf
I just realised that the codemeta was not packaged in the zenodo tar ball ;) I'll fix that asap.
requested review from @kay.graf
marked the checklist item It is under an open-source license (see SPDX [https://spdx.org/licenses/]) as completed
Thanks for the addition of the software package. In principle all necessary steps have been successfully completed. Some remarks that could be improved:
- There are 8 recommended keys missing in the meta data, some of them could be added:
['memoryRequirements' 'processorRequirements' 'releaseNotes' 'storageRequirements' 'copyrightHolder' 'funder' 'identifier' 'funding']
- Documentation could be better linked, e.g. in the Zenodo description directly, currently only via CodeMeta.
- The Zenodo entry for the current stable version 0.29.1 contains two tar balls:
- km3io-0.29.0.tar.gz (older version)
- km3io-0.29.1.tar.gz (current version)
- In the repository, there is a stable version 1.0.0, maybe you want to upgrade on this?
Edited by Kay Graf- There are 8 recommended keys missing in the meta data, some of them could be added:
@tamas.gal do you want to update the points above before we add the community or later on?
Documentation and repo URL have been added to the Zenodo description. I also added
'copyrightHolder'
and'releaseNotes'
. I released 1.0.1 with clean (single) tarball ;)Should I add ESCAPE/824064 to
funder/funding
to Codemeta? The Zenodo entry already has those.Edited by Tamás GálHere is the link: https://zenodo.org/record/8042522
- Resolved by Kay Graf
@jschnabel there is no onboarding issue for this entry (or I did not find it), so I could not follow this up.
removed Ready for curation label
added In curation Ready for curation labels
removed Ready for curation label